How to Set Boundaries Without Feeling Guilty – Especially If You're a People Pleaser
It can start with something small. You agree to stay late at work again, even though you're running on fumes. You lend money you can’t afford to spare. You agree to plans you never wanted to make. Then, when someone thanks you for being “so reliable,” you nod, even though what you really feel is resentment.
It’s at this point where your calendar starts looking less like a schedule and more like a public service announcement. This kind of overextending doesn’t come out of nowhere. For a lot of people pleasers, it’s a well-worn pattern – one that feels easier than the discomfort of letting someone down. And if that feels familiar to you, you probably also know how hard it is to start setting boundaries with yourself without feeling a nagging guilt.
So, why do you feel this way? Well, the urge to over-accommodate often stems from survival habits learned early in life. For instance, if you keep the peace and stay agreeable, you may just earn yourself some love through your usefulness. As Dr. Lauren Appio puts it, people pleasing is a “survival strategy” that can feel threatening to give up. Because when your value has been tied to being helpful, it’s easy to wonder who you are without that role.
Why Learning to Say No Feels So Unnatural
One of the biggest hurdles for people pleasers is that saying no feels almost abnormal. It threatens the very part of your identity that’s known for being “dependable” and “generous”. That’s why a firm boundary might feel like a rejection, and not just to others, but of your own character.
As Fara Tucker, a clinical social worker, explains, “many people pleasers never learned that they are separate people with needs and preferences who exist independent of their value to others. So when someone crosses your boundaries, it can feel like your only options are to cave or risk conflict.
That’s why even small decisions can carry so much weight. Take simply saying no, asking for space, or disagreeing with someone, for example. These are all “small things” that can actually bring up quite a bit of guilt and second-guessing. You might even feel pressure to explain yourself or apologize even when nothing was done wrong.
But each time you do hold steady, something in you shifts. You might begin to slow down and recognize what’s driving the urge to please, which is just the pause you need to create space for a different choice. Over time, those choices begin to reflect who you are and not just who you’ve tried to be for others.
Staying Steady When Someone Crosses Your Boundaries
For a lot of people pleasers, the fear of setting boundaries with yourself doesn’t stem from a single conversation. Instead, it comes from what might follow.
Will this person get angry at me for saying no? Will I be seen as selfish? Will they stop caring about me or stop reaching out altogether?
This kind of thought process can naturally shake your confidence. You might even feel like you have to explain yourself, soften the message, or reverse the decision altogether.
So sometimes, it helps just to be direct about the discomfort. A calm statement like “I know this might disappoint you” can take the tension right out of the moment. That way, you’re naming the feeling instead of trying to avoid it, and in doing so, you take away some of its power.
It can also help to speak from your own commitments. Saying something like “I promised myself I wouldn’t take on anything extra this week” places the decision in the context of your own care, not someone else’s expectations. People may not always like it, but they tend to respect it.
This shift might feel awkward at first, and that’s completely natural. In fact, it’s a good thing because that means you’re finally learning to show up for your own time in a new way. You’re choosing honesty over approval, which is a choice that becomes easier to make and more natural to carry every single day.
Boundaries Are a Form of Self-Respect, Not Selfishness
It’s important to remember, pleasing others isn’t the enemy. Thoughtfulness and generosity are beautiful traits. But when they come at the expense of your mental health, your goals, or your sense of agency, they stop being kind behavior and start being harmful.
Loose boundaries can lead to burnout, depression, and a loss of identity. You may even start to feel disconnected from yourself. It’s common to start forgetting what you enjoy, what you want, or even what you believe in, because everything revolves around keeping others happy. And ironically, that habit doesn’t bring closeness. It creates relationships where you can’t fully be seen, as you’re too busy performing.
So instead of aiming to keep every relationship intact, start nurturing the ones that feel reciprocal. If someone celebrates your limits, listens when you speak up, and respects your time? That’s a relationship worth investing in. On the other hand, if someone crosses your boundaries, despite knowing how you feel, well, that’s one to rethink.
Setting Boundaries Means Putting Yourself First
Learning how to set boundaries with yourself isn’t always easy, especially if you're used to defining your worth by how much you give. But it is one of the most meaningful shifts you can make in your relationship, with others and yourself. It allows you to stop pouring energy into people who only take and start investing in relationships that feel mutual, respectful, and authentic.
It’s time to protect your time, peace, and identity. Stop apologizing for needing space, and start making decisions that reflect what actually matters to you, rather than what will keep the peace in the moment.
There’s nothing small about this work. It is quiet but powerful, and the more you practice it, the more you begin to feel like yourself again – and less like someone auditioning for Most Likable Human 2025.
Try Therapy with Two Rivers Therapy Colorado.
If you're feeling burnt out, don't suffer in silence. Take action today by seeking professional burnout therapy. With the right help and support from our therapists for burnout in Colorado, you can overcome burnout and prevent it from taking a toll on your life and well-being. Don't wait any longer; prioritize your mental health with Two Rivers Therapy. Follow these simple steps on your journey toward recovery!
Meet with one of our skilled anxiety therapists.
Start overcoming your burnout symptoms and begin seeing positive changes in your life!
Other Services Offered at Two Rivers Therapy
At Two Rivers Therapy, we understand you may be struggling with multiple problems. To best support our clients in achieving optimal mental health and well-being, we offer anxiety therapy, depression treatment, trauma therapy, therapy for teens, and therapy for the overwhelmed and overworked. In addition to these services, we also offer clinical supervision to receive guidance and support from someone who has more experience than you may. To learn more, check out our blog or About Us!
